Difference between revisions of "Trading rules"
| (11 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
Make sure you’re okay with an offer-maker’s terms '''before''' you accept an offer! | Make sure you’re okay with an offer-maker’s terms '''before''' you accept an offer! | ||
| + | |||
| + | Trade rules also help with the following: | ||
| + | |||
| + | * Promoting good behavior from traders | ||
| + | * Penalizing bad behavior from traders | ||
| + | * Promoting good payment accounts of traders | ||
| + | * Penalizing bad payment accounts of traders | ||
| + | * Put the 'wrong doer' in a worse position and the person 'not at fault' in a better position | ||
= Rules for bitcoin sellers = | = Rules for bitcoin sellers = | ||
| Line 31: | Line 39: | ||
=== Do not confirm payments with mismatching details === | === Do not confirm payments with mismatching details === | ||
| − | Payer name, payment method, institution | + | Payer name, account numbers, payment method, institution, and other details of a payment should match the details in the trade contract. If there are any concerns that buyer's payment details do not match eg wrong name, account number etc payment should not be accepted.''' |
{{Admonition_Warn|This is especially relevant for trades in which a signed seller trades with an unsigned buyer, because confirmation of payment receipt signs the buyer’s payment account. In case of such an issue, a dispute should be opened.}} | {{Admonition_Warn|This is especially relevant for trades in which a signed seller trades with an unsigned buyer, because confirmation of payment receipt signs the buyer’s payment account. In case of such an issue, a dispute should be opened.}} | ||
| Line 37: | Line 45: | ||
=== Do not communicate with buyers away from Bisq === | === Do not communicate with buyers away from Bisq === | ||
| − | Using email addresses, phone numbers, and other means to contact traders is strongly discouraged. The trader chat feature built into Bisq should be used instead: not only is it more private, but the chat record can more easily be made available to mediators and arbitrators (useful in case a trader’s chat messages indicate they broke a rule). | + | Using email addresses, phone numbers, and other means to contact traders is strongly discouraged. The trader chat feature built into Bisq should be used instead: not only is it more private, but the chat record can more easily be made available to mediators and arbitrators (useful in case a trader’s chat messages indicate they broke a rule). This includes advertising offers to sell BTC with a way to contact you, for example a website, Telegram user name, or email. |
At this point, the software itself does not provide a way to relay the message record between 2 traders to a mediator or arbitrator, so other means of sharing the chat record will be used if needed. | At this point, the software itself does not provide a way to relay the message record between 2 traders to a mediator or arbitrator, so other means of sharing the chat record will be used if needed. | ||
| Line 50: | Line 58: | ||
This is especially important for buyers with unsigned payment accounts trading with sellers with signed payment accounts. A seller will not want to confirm receipt of a payment made at the last minute from an untrusted account, so if you’re a buyer looking to get your payment account signed, you should make the payment ''as soon as possible''. | This is especially important for buyers with unsigned payment accounts trading with sellers with signed payment accounts. A seller will not want to confirm receipt of a payment made at the last minute from an untrusted account, so if you’re a buyer looking to get your payment account signed, you should make the payment ''as soon as possible''. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Some payment methods include an option to cancel a payment after you have sent it eg Revolut and Interac e-Transfer. If you cancel payment without agreement with the seller or mediator you might end up being penalized for cancelling the trade. | ||
=== Use same payment account in trade contract === | === Use same payment account in trade contract === | ||
| Line 63: | Line 73: | ||
Don’t forget to do this! | Don’t forget to do this! | ||
| − | === | + | === Leave the "reason for payment" field empty === |
| + | |||
| + | {{Admonition_Warn|Before 1.5.5, it was required to put the trade ID in the 'reason for payment' field of a payment. As of 1.5.5, reason for payment should be left BLANK.}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | Some payments offer a way to specify a reason for payment (some payment methods call it "Message" or "Information for recipient" or similar). '''Leave this field BLANK.''' Do not put the trade ID, any mentions of "Bisq" or "Bitcoin" or "crypto", or any other text whatsoever. | ||
| − | If | + | If you are required to fill in a reason, use your account name eg "Joe Bloggs" alternatively enter something non-descriptive like a dash "-". If you would prefer to use other text please agree this with your peer in trader chat. Please remember your peer is not obligated to agree anything and may not want to agree to anything other than leaving the description blank, your name or a dash. |
| − | + | Violating this rule will likely result in a [[Table of penalties|trade penalty]]. | |
| − | + | Many banks don’t like anything related to Bitcoin, and may take draconian measures if they sense such a transaction. | |
| − | + | Many users trade from personal accounts and may object to using anything that looks like it could be a commercial transaction. | |
=== Pay any transaction fees === | === Pay any transaction fees === | ||
| Line 87: | Line 101: | ||
=== Do not communicate with sellers away from Bisq === | === Do not communicate with sellers away from Bisq === | ||
| − | Using email addresses, phone numbers, and other means to contact traders is strongly discouraged. The trader chat feature built into Bisq should be used instead: not only is it more private, but the chat record can more easily be made available to mediators and arbitrators (useful in case a trader’s chat messages indicate they broke a rule). | + | Using email addresses, phone numbers, and other means to contact traders is strongly discouraged. The trader chat feature built into Bisq should be used instead: not only is it more private, but the chat record can more easily be made available to mediators and arbitrators (useful in case a trader’s chat messages indicate they broke a rule). This includes advertising offers to buy BTC with a way to contact you for example; a website, Telegram user name, or email. |
At this point, the software itself does not provide a way to relay the message record between 2 traders to a mediator or arbitrator, so other means of sharing the chat record will be used if needed. | At this point, the software itself does not provide a way to relay the message record between 2 traders to a mediator or arbitrator, so other means of sharing the chat record will be used if needed. | ||
| + | |||
| + | = What happens when things go wrong? = | ||
| + | |||
| + | Sometimes trades do not go to plan for whatever reason. | ||
| + | |||
| + | It is prudent for all traders to know when entering into the trade what will happen when things go wrong. Traders would be wise to make themselves aware of the [[dispute resolution]] process to ensure there are no surprises. | ||
Latest revision as of 20:30, 12 June 2023
Both Bisq traders must follow these trading rules to ensure smooth and successful trades.
To trade on Bisq, you assume one of two roles, no matter what national currency or cryptocurrency you’re trading: you either buy bitcoin or sell bitcoin.
The rules below are default rules for every transaction. Offer makers sometimes specify their own additional terms for handling payments. For example, a seller using cash deposits might require a picture of a receipt torn in half with "NO REFUND" written on it. Face-to-face traders often specify terms about where and how to meet.
Make sure you’re okay with an offer-maker’s terms before you accept an offer!
Trade rules also help with the following:
- Promoting good behavior from traders
- Penalizing bad behavior from traders
- Promoting good payment accounts of traders
- Penalizing bad payment accounts of traders
- Put the 'wrong doer' in a worse position and the person 'not at fault' in a better position
Contents
- 1 Rules for bitcoin sellers
- 2 Rules for bitcoin buyers
- 2.1 Make payment reasonably early within trade period
- 2.2 Use same payment account in trade contract
- 2.3 Click Payment started after sending payment
- 2.4 Leave the "reason for payment" field empty
- 2.5 Pay any transaction fees
- 2.6 Collaborate with mediators and arbitrators
- 2.7 Do not communicate with sellers away from Bisq
- 3 What happens when things go wrong?
Rules for bitcoin sellers
Whether making or taking an offer, bitcoin sellers put all the bitcoin they’re selling in the multisig escrow, so there’s less for them to do and fewer rules they need to follow.
Click Confirm payment after receiving payment
Sellers have until the end of the maximum trade period to do so.
Account signing, introduced in Bisq v1.2, enables a seller with a signed payment account to sign a buyer’s payment account when they successfully receive a payment. For such trades, it is recommended that the seller take as long as possible (i.e., wait until close to the end of the trade period) to confirm receipt of payment to reduce the chance of a chargeback.
Collaborate with mediators and arbitrators
In case of a dispute, users must respond to inquiries within 48 hours and providing materials as requested to determine an outcome.
Mediators may take up to 48 hours to respond to messages, and arbitrators may take up to 5 days to respond to messages.
Do not change payment details once trade is in progress
Once the deposit transaction is published, the trade is in progress, and its terms cannot be changed. The seller had agreed to be paid as specified in the trade contract.
In the event of an unexpected circumstance (e.g., hitting a bank-imposed transfer limit), seller can propose alternatives through trader chat or mediation, but buyer is not required to comply. It is the seller to ensure that the payment account in their offer will work before an offer is taken.
Do not confirm payments with mismatching details
Payer name, account numbers, payment method, institution, and other details of a payment should match the details in the trade contract. If there are any concerns that buyer's payment details do not match eg wrong name, account number etc payment should not be accepted.
 |
This is especially relevant for trades in which a signed seller trades with an unsigned buyer, because confirmation of payment receipt signs the buyer’s payment account. In case of such an issue, a dispute should be opened. |
Do not communicate with buyers away from Bisq
Using email addresses, phone numbers, and other means to contact traders is strongly discouraged. The trader chat feature built into Bisq should be used instead: not only is it more private, but the chat record can more easily be made available to mediators and arbitrators (useful in case a trader’s chat messages indicate they broke a rule). This includes advertising offers to sell BTC with a way to contact you, for example a website, Telegram user name, or email.
At this point, the software itself does not provide a way to relay the message record between 2 traders to a mediator or arbitrator, so other means of sharing the chat record will be used if needed.
Rules for bitcoin buyers
|
To avoid unexpected issues, make sure you can actually carry out a payment with the payment method you’ve set up in Bisq. Examples: Wells Fargo doesn’t allow cash deposits into bank accounts not owned by the depositor, and Zelle has weekly and monthly transfer maximums that are easy to overlook. The software will warn you about known issues, but cannot possibly keep up with all the newest banking and money transfer rules. |
Make payment reasonably early within trade period
Buyer should complete at a time such that the seller has enough time to acknowledge receipt of the payment before the trade period is over. Waiting until the very end of the trade period to make a payment is not advised, as then the seller cannot reasonably act in time to acknowledge receipt (also, it’s annoying). The lengths of trade periods vary based on payment method.
This is especially important for buyers with unsigned payment accounts trading with sellers with signed payment accounts. A seller will not want to confirm receipt of a payment made at the last minute from an untrusted account, so if you’re a buyer looking to get your payment account signed, you should make the payment as soon as possible.
Some payment methods include an option to cancel a payment after you have sent it eg Revolut and Interac e-Transfer. If you cancel payment without agreement with the seller or mediator you might end up being penalized for cancelling the trade.
Use same payment account in trade contract
Intermediary banks or other payment methods from the same bank are not acceptable. Account information (e.g., name, account number, etc) of the account used to make the payment must exactly match the information in the Bisq payment account details.
If such a payment cannot be made, please communicate the issue through trader chat, or you’ll need to make your case to a mediator or arbitrator.
Click Payment started after sending payment
Seller cannot mark payment as received until buyer confirms that they have sent it.
Don’t forget to do this!
Leave the "reason for payment" field empty
|
Before 1.5.5, it was required to put the trade ID in the 'reason for payment' field of a payment. As of 1.5.5, reason for payment should be left BLANK. |
Some payments offer a way to specify a reason for payment (some payment methods call it "Message" or "Information for recipient" or similar). Leave this field BLANK. Do not put the trade ID, any mentions of "Bisq" or "Bitcoin" or "crypto", or any other text whatsoever.
If you are required to fill in a reason, use your account name eg "Joe Bloggs" alternatively enter something non-descriptive like a dash "-". If you would prefer to use other text please agree this with your peer in trader chat. Please remember your peer is not obligated to agree anything and may not want to agree to anything other than leaving the description blank, your name or a dash.
Violating this rule will likely result in a trade penalty.
Many banks don’t like anything related to Bitcoin, and may take draconian measures if they sense such a transaction.
Many users trade from personal accounts and may object to using anything that looks like it could be a commercial transaction.
Pay any transaction fees
Any fees incurred to make the payment via the agreed payment method (e.g., bank fees for bank transfer, money-order fees for money orders, etc) are the buyer’s responsibility to pay.
The seller should receive the exact amount of the trade. The only exception to this rule is if the receiving institution imposes a fee on incoming payments—these fees are borne by the seller.
Collaborate with mediators and arbitrators
In case of a dispute, users must respond to inquiries within 48 hours and providing materials as requested to determine an outcome.
Mediators may take up to 48 hours to respond to messages, and arbitrators may take up to 5 days to respond to messages.
Do not communicate with sellers away from Bisq
Using email addresses, phone numbers, and other means to contact traders is strongly discouraged. The trader chat feature built into Bisq should be used instead: not only is it more private, but the chat record can more easily be made available to mediators and arbitrators (useful in case a trader’s chat messages indicate they broke a rule). This includes advertising offers to buy BTC with a way to contact you for example; a website, Telegram user name, or email.
At this point, the software itself does not provide a way to relay the message record between 2 traders to a mediator or arbitrator, so other means of sharing the chat record will be used if needed.
What happens when things go wrong?
Sometimes trades do not go to plan for whatever reason.
It is prudent for all traders to know when entering into the trade what will happen when things go wrong. Traders would be wise to make themselves aware of the dispute resolution process to ensure there are no surprises.
