Reputation - Revision history

Strayorigin at 06:22, 6 May 2025

2025-05-06T06:22:27Z

Strayorigin: Update Account Age & Signed Account Age import steps & scoring details to match current UI.

2025-05-06T06:08:24Z

Update Account Age & Signed Account Age import steps & scoring details to match current UI.

Show changes

Strayorigin: updated with 2.1.6 security update info

2025-04-17T03:41:50Z

updated with 2.1.6 security update info

Strayorigin: reworded for clarity, flow and format

2025-04-05T16:59:16Z

reworded for clarity, flow and format

Show changes

Strayorigin: reworded for clarity and format

2025-04-05T16:43:15Z

reworded for clarity and format

Strayorigin: /* Minimum and maximum trade amounts */ reworded for clarity

2025-04-05T16:34:41Z

Minimum and maximum trade amounts: reworded for clarity

Strayorigin: changed to reflect security update changes from 2.1.6

2025-04-05T16:31:53Z

changed to reflect security update changes from 2.1.6

Pazza: /* Burning BSQ */

2024-10-04T02:25:59Z

Burning BSQ

Pazza: /* Setting up a BSQ bond */

2024-10-04T02:25:47Z

Setting up a BSQ bond

Pazza: /* Burning BSQ */

2024-10-04T02:25:03Z

Burning BSQ

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 {{Admonition_Warn|'''Important Version Requirement:''' Please note that due to security updates, active trading on the Bisq network requires using software '''version 2.1.6 or higher'''. The reputation system described here applies to users on compatible versions participating in the [[Bisq Easy]] protocol.}}
-[[File:Bisq2-build-reputation-screen.png|600px|thumb|left|The 'Build reputation' screen in Bisq 2, showing the four methods available.]] <br clear=all>
+[[File:Bisq2-build-reputation-screen.png|600px|thumb|left|The 'Build reputation' screen in Bisq 2 (accessed via 'Reputation' on the left menu), showing the four methods available.]] <br clear=all>
 === Why Reputation Matters ===
@@ Line 33: / Line 33: @@
 * '''How it Works (Relative Ranking):''' Your star rating shows how your reputation '''compares to all other *active* users''' on the Bisq network at that moment. It's your current rank, not a fixed score. The highest-ranked active sellers get 5 stars, the lowest get 0 stars.
 * '''Why Stars Change (Dynamic):''' Because it's a relative system based on active users, your star rating can change even if your score hasn't:
-    * '''User Inactivity:''' If a user is inactive for '''two weeks''', their profile is temporarily excluded from the ranking calculation. If a high-ranked user becomes inactive, others might see their star ratings go up.
+:'''User Inactivity:''' If a user is inactive for '''two weeks''', their profile is temporarily excluded from the ranking calculation. If a high-ranked user becomes inactive, others might see their star ratings go up.
-    * '''User Reactivation:''' When an inactive user returns, their reputation is factored back in, potentially shifting star ratings again.
+:'''User Reactivation:''' When an inactive user returns, their reputation is factored back in, potentially shifting star ratings again.
 '''In short:''' Stars give you a quick, dynamic view of a seller's current reputation rank compared to their active peers. The star display will change over time based on both your own score changes and the changing scores of other active users.
@@ Line 41: / Line 41: @@
 == How to Build Reputation ==
-You can build your reputation score in [[Bisq Easy]] using four methods, accessed via `User Options` > `Reputation` in Bisq 2. Your '''total reputation score''' is calculated as the '''sum''' of the points gained from all methods you use. This total score determines your reputation rank (stars) and your maximum trade offer size.
+You can build your reputation score in [[Bisq Easy]] using four methods, accessed via the '''`Reputation`''' section on the main left-hand menu in Bisq 2. Your '''total reputation score''' is calculated as the '''sum''' of the points gained from all methods you use. This total score determines your reputation rank (stars) and your maximum trade offer size.
 Reputation scores can change over time: points from [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] Bonds are lost when unlocked, but you can burn or bond [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] repeatedly. You can also import account age or signed account age, potentially replacing previous imported scores if the new import source is older.
@@ Line 143: / Line 143: @@
 Deciding how much [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] to burn or bond can be complex. [[Bisq 2]] provides a simulation tool (visible on the 'SCORE' tab for Burning/Bonding/Import methods) to help sellers estimate the reputation score impact of these actions.
-Find this tool within the 'Reputation' section ('User Options' > `Reputation`). It helps visualize the immediate score increase and the potential score after the first year's doubling effect (for BSQ methods) or based on account age.
+Find this tool within the '''`Reputation`''' section (accessible from the main left-hand menu). It helps visualize the immediate score increase and the potential score after the first year's doubling effect (for BSQ methods) or based on account age.
 [[File:Burning-bsq-screen.png|400px|thumb|left|Simulating the reputation gained from burning [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]].]]
@@ Line 151: / Line 151: @@
 == What Happens if a Profile is Banned? ==
-If a user's profile ID (which contains a public key hash tied to reputation) is banned by [[Bisq 2 Roles|moderators]] for severe or repeated violations of Bisq trade protocols, '''all reputation associated with that specific profile ID is permanently lost''' and becomes unusable. The reputation score will no longer be visible or count towards rankings. Banning may also trigger consequences in [[Bisq 1]] (e.g., [[Changing_your_onion_address|onion address]] ban, [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] bond confiscation proposal via the [[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]).Update Account Age & Signed Account Age import steps & scoring details to match current UI.
+If a user's profile ID (which contains a public key hash tied to reputation) is banned by [[Bisq 2 Roles|moderators]] for severe or repeated violations of Bisq trade protocols, '''all reputation associated with that specific profile ID is permanently lost''' and becomes unusable. The reputation score will no longer be visible or count towards rankings. Banning may also trigger consequences in [[Bisq 1]] (e.g., [[Changing_your_onion_address|onion address]] ban, [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] bond confiscation proposal via the [[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]).

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 Reputation is a cornerstone of the security model in '''[[Bisq Easy]]''', a [[Bisq 2]] trade protocol. As buyers send their fiat payment ''before'' receiving Bitcoin, the seller's reputation provides the trust needed for the buyer to proceed confidently.
 [[File:Reputation-section-new.png|400px|thumb|left|The main Reputation section can be found under 'User Options' in the [[Bisq 2]] left-hand menu.]]
@@ Line 9: / Line 11: @@
 * '''For Buyers:''' Carefully review a seller's reputation (shown as stars) before accepting an offer. Choosing sellers with a higher reputation is crucial for minimizing trade risks.
-* '''For Sellers:''' Building and maintaining a high reputation is essential. It increases buyer trust, makes your offers more competitive leading to more trades, and '''allows you to offer larger trade amounts''' (see rules below). Maximizing reputation is key to success as a seller on [[Bisq Easy]]. There is expected to be competition among sellers to achieve higher reputation scores.
+* '''For Sellers:''' Building and maintaining a high reputation is essential. It increases buyer trust, makes your offers more attractive, helps you get more trades, and allows you to offer larger trade amounts. Maximizing reputation is key to success as a seller on [[Bisq Easy]]. There is expected to be competition among sellers to achieve higher reputation scores.
 === Reputation & Trade Rules (Version 2.1.1 and Later) ===
-Starting with '''[[Bisq 2]] version 2.1.1''', several important rules directly link reputation to trading activity:
+Starting with '''[[Bisq 2]] version 2.1.1''', several important rules link reputation directly to trading activity (within the currently required software version):
 * '''Seller's Maximum Trade Amount:''' The maximum amount a seller can offer in a single trade now directly depends on their reputation score. Higher reputation allows sellers to create offers for larger amounts.
@@ Line 60: / Line 62: @@
 * '''How To Burn BSQ for Reputation:'''
      # In [[Bisq 2]]: Go to 'User Options' > 'Reputation'. Select your profile and copy the '''Profile ID'''.
-     # In '''Bisq 1''': Go to '[[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]' > 'PROOF OF BURN'.
+     # In '''[[Bisq 1]]''': Go to '[[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]' > 'PROOF OF BURN'.
      # Paste the [[Bisq 2]] Profile ID into the '''pre-image''' field.
      # Enter the amount of [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] you want to burn.
@@ Line 66: / Line 68: @@
      # After blockchain confirmation, the reputation will appear on your [[Bisq 2]] profile.
-[[File:Burning-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Burning [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] in Bisq 1 requires your [[Bisq 2]] Profile ID as the 'pre-image'.]]
+[[File:Burning-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Burning [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] in [[Bisq 1]] requires your [[Bisq 2]] Profile ID as the 'pre-image'.]]
 <br clear=all>
@@ Line 83: / Line 85: @@
 * '''How To Bond BSQ for Reputation:'''
      # In [[Bisq 2]]: Go to 'User Options' > 'Reputation'. Select your profile and copy the '''Profile ID'''.
-     # In '''Bisq 1''': Go to '[[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]' > 'BONDING' > 'BONDED REPUTATION'.
+     # In '''[[Bisq 1]]''': Go to '[[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]' > 'BONDING' > 'BONDED REPUTATION'.
      # Paste the [[Bisq 2]] Profile ID into the '''salt''' field.
      # Enter the [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] amount and set lock time to at least '''50000''' blocks.
@@ Line 89: / Line 91: @@
      # After blockchain confirmation, the reputation appears on your [[Bisq 2]] profile.
-[[File:Bonding-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Bonding [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] in Bisq 1 uses your [[Bisq 2]] Profile ID as the 'salt'.]]
+[[File:Bonding-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Bonding [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] in [[Bisq 1]] uses your [[Bisq 2]] Profile ID as the 'salt'.]]
 <br clear=all>
 === Method 3: Importing Bisq 1 Account Age ===
-Leverage the history of your fiat accounts from Bisq 1. The older the account, the more trustworthy the user is assumed to be.
+Leverage the history of your fiat accounts from [[Bisq 1]]. The older the account, the more trustworthy the user is assumed to be.
 * '''Scoring:'''
      * Score: '''2.5 points''' per day of the account's age.
      * Maximum: Capped at '''5,000 points''' (for accounts ~2000 days old or older).
-     * Which Account: Uses the age of your single '''oldest''' Bisq 1 fiat account. Scores from multiple accounts are '''not''' added together. If you import again from an even older account later, it can replace the previous score from this method.
+     * Which Account: Uses the age of your single '''oldest''' [[Bisq 1]] fiat account. Scores from multiple accounts are '''not''' added together. If you import again from an even older account later, it can replace the previous score from this method.
      * Limitation: Account age alone is usually '''not enough''' for significant reputation; combine with other methods.
 * '''How To Import Account Age:'''
      # In [[Bisq 2]]: Go to 'User Options' > 'Reputation' > 'Account Age'. Select profile, copy '''Profile ID'''.
-     # In '''Bisq 1''': Go to 'ACCOUNT' > 'NATIONAL CURRENCY ACCOUNTS'.
+     # In '''[[Bisq 1]]''': Go to 'ACCOUNT' > 'NATIONAL CURRENCY ACCOUNTS'.
      # Select your oldest account and click '''Export Account'''.
      # Copy the generated signature/proof.
@@ Line 109: / Line 111: @@
      # Click 'Request authorization'.
-[[File:Age-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Importing account age requires exporting proof from your oldest Bisq 1 account.]]
+[[File:Age-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Importing account age requires exporting proof from your oldest [[Bisq 1]] account.]]
 <br clear=all>
 === Method 4: Importing Bisq 1 Signed Account Age ===
-Similar to account age, but uses the age of fiat accounts that completed the older signing process in Bisq 1. The older the signed account, the more trustworthy the user is assumed to be.
+Similar to account age, but uses the age of fiat accounts that completed the older signing process in [[Bisq 1]]. The older the signed account, the more trustworthy the user is assumed to be.
 * '''Scoring:'''
      * Score: '''5 points''' per day of the signed account's age.
      * Maximum: Capped at '''10,000 points''' (for signed accounts ~2000 days old or older).
-     * Which Account: Uses the age of your single '''oldest''' Bisq 1 ''signed'' fiat account. Scores are '''not''' cumulative across multiple signed accounts. Importing from an older signed account later can replace a previous score from this method.
+     * Which Account: Uses the age of your single '''oldest''' [[Bisq 1]] ''signed'' fiat account. Scores are '''not''' cumulative across multiple signed accounts. Importing from an older signed account later can replace a previous score from this method.
      * Limitation: Signed account age alone may '''not be enough''' for higher reputation tiers; combine with other methods.
 * '''How To Import Signed Account Age:'''
      # In [[Bisq 2]]: Go to 'User Options' > 'Reputation' > 'Signed Account Age'. Select profile, copy '''Profile ID'''.
-     # In '''Bisq 1''': Go to 'ACCOUNT' > 'NATIONAL CURRENCY ACCOUNTS'.
+     # In '''[[Bisq 1]]''': Go to 'ACCOUNT' > 'NATIONAL CURRENCY ACCOUNTS'.
      # Select your oldest ''signed'' account and click '''Export Account'''.
      # Copy the generated signature/proof.
@@ Line 129: / Line 131: @@
      # Click 'Request authorization'.
-[[File:Signed-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Importing signed account age uses proof from your oldest signed Bisq 1 account.]]
+[[File:Signed-bsq-reputation.png|frame|left|Importing signed account age uses proof from your oldest signed [[Bisq 1]] account.]]
 <br clear=all>
@@ Line 144: / Line 146: @@
 == What Happens if a Profile is Banned? ==
-If a user's profile ID (which contains a public key hash tied to reputation) is banned by moderators for severe or repeated violations of Bisq trade protocols, '''all reputation associated with that specific profile ID is permanently lost'''. The score will no longer be visible or count towards rankings. Banning may also trigger consequences in Bisq 1 (e.g., onion address ban, [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] bond confiscation proposal via the [[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]).
+If a user's profile ID (which contains a public key hash tied to reputation) is banned by moderators for severe or repeated violations of Bisq trade protocols, '''all reputation associated with that specific profile ID is permanently lost''' and becomes unusable. The reputation score will no longer be visible or count towards rankings. Banning may also trigger consequences in [[Bisq 1]] (e.g., onion address ban, [[Introduction to the DAO|BSQ]] bond confiscation proposal via the [[Introduction to the DAO|DAO]]).

@@ Line 62: / Line 62: @@
-== Reputation score star system ==
+== Understanding Reputation Stars ==
-To make it easier for user's to compare the reputation scores of different traders, Bisq displays reputation scores as stars (0-5 stars).
+To quickly see how reputable a seller is, Bisq uses a simple '''0 to 5 star system''' instead of showing complex reputation scores. More stars mean a better reputation.
-To achieve this users' total reputation scores are compared to other scores in the network and ranked and normalized to a value between 0 and 1.
+[[File:Reputation-ranking-new.png|400px|thumb|left|Bisq's star system makes it easy to compare seller reputations at a glance. 5 stars indicate the highest-ranked active sellers.]]
-The user with the highest ranking will have a value of 5 stars. The user with the lowest ranking will have a value of 0 stars.
+=== How Star Ratings Work ===
-The user profiles only stay for 2 weeks in the network in case a user is not active. Thus their associated reputation will disappear with their profile if being inactive for 2 weeks. This has an impact on the relative reputation score of all other users. For instance if the user with the highest reputation is inactive and gets removed from the network the next user with the highest reputation will become the highest ranked with 5 star. Once a inactive user becomes active again their reputation score will be taken into account in the relative ranking.
+Your star rating isn't fixed; it shows how your reputation '''compares to all other *active* users''' on the Bisq network right now.
-One could phrase it as: The reputation score star system is the relative ranking compared to the reputation of the active users in the network.
+* Sellers with the highest reputation compared to others currently active receive '''5 stars'''.
-[[File:Reputation-ranking-new.png|400px|thumb|left|Bisq converts a seller's reputation score into an easy to view star system. This makes it easy for buyers to see at a glance which are the most reputable sellers. The sellers with the highest reputation have 5 stars and the sellers with the lowest reputation will have 0 stars.]]
+=== Why Star Ratings Can Change ===
 <br clear=all>

@@ Line 33: / Line 33: @@
 * '''Enhanced BSQ Value:''' Version 2.1.1 introduced an update to the reputation score calculation. Both '''burned BSQ''' and '''bonded BSQ''' now contribute '''twice their value''' towards the reputation score during the first year after the burn or bond transaction. This allows sellers to increase their eligible trade limits more quickly.
-== Minimum and maximum trade amounts ==
+== Minimum and Maximum Trade Amounts ==
-Prior to v2.1.1 the minimum and maximum trade amounts were set to 0.0001 - 0.01 BTC. With v2.1.1 we use the fixed fiat amount (independent of Bitcoin price) of 6 USD - 600 USD (converted to the chosen currency). This avoids fluctuations in case of price volatility.
+Before '''v2.1.1''', the minimum and maximum trade amounts were defined in Bitcoin (BTC) terms, ranging from 0.0001 BTC to 0.01 BTC.
-[[File:Minimum-maximum-trade-amounts.png|400px|thumb|left|The minimum and maximum trade amounts for Bisq 2 Easy are between 6 USD and 600 USD or your chosen fiat equivalent]]
+Starting with '''v2.1.1''', Bisq Easy uses fixed fiat amount limits to reduce the impact of BTC price volatility. The general range for trades is now between the equivalent of '''6 USD''' (minimum) and '''600 USD''' (maximum), automatically converted to your chosen fiat currency.
 <br clear=all>

@@ Line 13: / Line 13: @@
 <br clear=all>
-== Reputation based trade limits ==
+== Reputation in Bisq Easy ==
-A seller can take offers up to the amount derived from their reputation score.
+The security model of '''Bisq Easy''' (a [[Bisq 2]] trade protocol) is based on the '''seller's reputation'''.
-The formula is: `Reputation score / 200 = max. trade amount in USD`. In other words, for each USD the seller needs 200 reputation points. A reputation score of 30000 enables trades up to 150 USD (converted to the chosen fiat currency).
+=== Why Reputation Matters ===
-For small trade amounts of the value 25 USD and below, this restriction is lifted. This is motivated by the lower risk of such small amounts and to give users more flexibility.
+=== Guidance for Buyers ===
-The reputation based trade limits means a buyer creating an offer can be sure the taker (seller) has an adequate reputation score. In case the offer allows amounts below 25 USD anyone with low or no reputation can take the offer. Maker's who do not want to allow users with no reputation to be able to take their offer should create offers higher than 25 USD.
+=== Guidance for Sellers ===
 == Minimum and maximum trade amounts ==

@@ Line 108: / Line 108: @@
 The minimum amount of BSQ that can be burnt is 5.46 BSQ (dust limit).
-The reputation score achieved by burning BSQ increases linearly over the first twelve months. At the end of the 12 months the reputation score gained will be double what it was initially. This is to give an advantage to seller's over the long term.
+The reputation score achieved by burning BSQ increases linearly over the first twelve months. At the end of the 12 months the reputation score gained will be double what it was initially. This is to give an advantage to sellers over the long term.
 The value gained by burning BSQ persists over time. Reputation scores achieved from burning BSQ is cumulative. It can be assumed that regular burning (e.g. each week or month) is a form of work and represents activity by the user resulting in a higher reputation score.

@@ Line 150: / Line 150: @@
 BSQ needs to be bonded for a minimum of 50,000 blocks (about 1 year). During this time the BSQ is unavailable to the user. After 50,000 blocks the bond can be unlocked and the BSQ is available again to the user.
 The value gained by bonding BSQ persists until the time the bond is unlocked. Reputation scores achieved from bonding BSQ is cumulative. It can be assumed that regular bonding (e.g. each week or month) is a form of work and represents activity by the user resulting in a higher reputation score.
@@ Line 176: / Line 178: @@
 Bonding BSQ has a high impact on the reputation score.
-For every BSQ bonded the user receives a reputation score of 10. This amount will increase linearly over the frist twelve months until it doubles.
+For every BSQ bonded the user receives a reputation score of 10. This amount will increase linearly over the first twelve months until it doubles.
 For example if a user bonds 1,000 BSQ their reputation score will be increased by 10,000 immediately, and by the end of the 12 months it will have increased to 20,000.

@@ Line 107: / Line 107: @@
 The minimum amount of BSQ that can be burnt is 5.46 BSQ (dust limit).
 The value gained by burning BSQ persists over time. Reputation scores achieved from burning BSQ is cumulative. It can be assumed that regular burning (e.g. each week or month) is a form of work and represents activity by the user resulting in a higher reputation score.
@@ Line 133: / Line 135: @@
 Burning BSQ has the highest impact on the reputation score.
-For every BSQ burnt the user receives a reputation score of 100. This amount will increase linearly over the frist twelve months until it doubles.
+For every BSQ burnt the user receives a reputation score of 100. This amount will increase linearly over the first twelve months until it doubles.
 For example if a user burns 100 BSQ their reputation score will be increased by 10,000 immediately, and by the end of the 12 months it will have increased to 20,000.