Compensation - Revision history

Pazza at 15:47, 25 August 2024

2024-08-25T15:47:25Z

Plebeian9000 at 22:08, 9 April 2021

2021-04-09T22:08:44Z

Plebeian9000: /* Compensation Maintainer */

2021-04-09T16:55:30Z

Compensation Maintainer

Plebeian9000: tighten focus of sections; move longer sections to their own pages

2021-04-09T16:55:11Z

tighten focus of sections; move longer sections to their own pages

Plebeian9000: move compensation role description to the compensation role page

2021-04-09T14:52:16Z

move compensation role description to the compensation role page

MwithM: /* Compensation Maintainer */ Propose BSQ rate at submission deadline.

2020-11-09T08:14:59Z

Compensation Maintainer: Propose BSQ rate at submission deadline.

Bayer: /* Submit your request as a DAO proposal */

2020-09-22T16:09:25Z

Submit your request as a DAO proposal

Bayer: /* Create your compensation request issue */

2020-09-22T15:43:19Z

Create your compensation request issue

Wiz: /* Incorporate review feedback for your request */

2020-06-20T18:59:47Z

Incorporate review feedback for your request

MwithM: /* Submit your request as a DAO proposal */ comment to add "waiting for team lead review"

2020-06-20T16:40:57Z

Submit your request as a DAO proposal: comment to add "waiting for team lead review"

@@ Line 17: / Line 17: @@
 If you'd like to contribute to Bisq but are unsure where to start, check out the [[contributor checklist]].
-== Team Lead ==
+== Burning Men ==
-Team leads do an initial review before voting to evaluate whether a compensation request is warranted, appropriate (e.g. whether the work meets the definition of delivered), and in line with team priorities and budget.
+Any contributor can also act as Burning Man. This is part of Bisq's decentralized [[Burning Men]] protocol. Contributors to Bisq can choose to burn the BSQ they receive to have a chance of receive bitcoin trade fees paid by traders. The process of burning BSQ also help strengthen the DAO by decreasing the BSQ supply.
 == Stakeholder ==

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:08, 9 April 2021
Line 1:		Line 1:
−	'''Compensation''' is an important element of the [[Decentralized_autonomous_organization\|Bisq DAO]] that incentivizes people to contribute to the Bisq software and, ~~consequently~~, enables them to take on a greater stake in its governance.	+	'''Compensation''' is an important element of the [[Decentralized_autonomous_organization\|Bisq DAO]] that incentivizes people to contribute to the Bisq software and, over time, enables them to take on a greater stake in its governance.

	This article covers the several parties involved in the process of requesting, approving, issuing, and guiding compensation.		This article covers the several parties involved in the process of requesting, approving, issuing, and guiding compensation.

@@ Line 7: / Line 7: @@
 == Compensation Maintainer ==
-The compensation maintainer oversees the day-to-day process of compensation requests, triages issues, and determines rates. See the [[Compensation Maintainer]] article for more details on this role.
+The compensation maintainer oversees the day-to-day process of compensation requests, triages issues, and determines rates.
 == Contributor ==

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-__TOC__
+'''Compensation''' is an important element of the [[Decentralized_autonomous_organization|Bisq DAO]] that incentivizes people to contribute to the Bisq software and, consequently, enables them to take on a greater stake in its governance.
-== Processes by role ==
+This article covers the several parties involved in the process of requesting, approving, issuing, and guiding compensation.
-=== Compensation Maintainer ===
+__TOC__
-To more efficiently evaluate issuance for budgeting, compensation requests are evaluated by a bot. This bot requires that compensation requests follow a particular format. This format is detailed in the placeholder text for new compensation request issues—just follow the guidelines there, and/or look at other requests if you're not sure about something.
+== Compensation Maintainer ==
-In order to make sure the bot can actually read the request, requests are linted as soon as they are ready for review (i.e., as soon as <code>[WIP]</code> is removed from the issue title). A request is labeled <code>parsed:valid</code> if it's valid, <code>parsed:invalid</code> if it's not. If invalid, a comment is added indicating the error. Please watch for this label and fix any errors the linter finds.
+The compensation maintainer oversees the day-to-day process of compensation requests, triages issues, and determines rates. See the [[Compensation Maintainer]] article for more details on this role.
-==== Incorporate review feedback for your request ====
+== Contributor ==
-When your team lead or other stakeholders review your compensation request, they will provide any feedback or requests for changes in the form of a comment on your request issue. Please respond to it promptly. When there is no further feedback, your team lead will add a comment asking you to submit this compensation request as a DAO proposal. The instructions how to do so are in the next section.
+Contributors are welcome to create compensation requests for work they've done on the Bisq project. See instructions in [[Making_a_compensation_request|this guide]].
-Exception: If your contribution proposal consists solely of Bonded Roles for the Ops Team, which are pre-approved in the Ops Budget and allocated to you, and you are still running those nodes as expected, then you can skip the Team Lead Review as per https://github.com/orgs/bisq-network/teams/ops/discussions/1
+If you'd like to contribute to Bisq but are unsure where to start, check out the [[contributor checklist]].
-==== Submit your request as a DAO proposal ====
+== Team Lead ==
-Follow the instructions on how to [[File_compensation_request_in_the_DAO|file your compensation request as a DAO proposal]]. When complete, add a comment to your proposal issue that includes the transaction ID of your proposal. <!-- Wait until team lead review is complete before taking this step -->
+Team leads do an initial review before voting to evaluate whether a compensation request is warranted, appropriate (e.g. whether the work meets the definition of delivered), and in line with team priorities and budget.
-=== Team Lead ===
+When a new compensation request is submitted, the assigned team lead should promptly review it, add feedback as a appropriate, and request changes as necessary.
-==== Review team member requests ====
+When feedback has been addressed, the team lead will ask the contributor to submit their proposal to the DAO and post the resulting TXID in a comment.
-When a team lead is assigned to a compensation request issue, they should promptly review it with regard to whether the work meets the definition of delivered, and whether it fits within the team budget. The team lead should add feedback and comments as a appropriate, and assign the contributor to the issue to indicate that they are expected to respond to the review.
+== Stakeholder ==
-When the review process is complete, i.e. all team lead feedback has been addressed, the team lead should add a comment asking the contributor to submit their proposal to DAO and to post the resulting TXID in a comment.
+Just as stakeholders may review and vote on any DAO proposal, stakeholders may review and vote on any contributor's compensation request. After all, compensation requests are merely another type of DAO proposal.
-=== Stakeholder ===
+No special permissions are needed—a stakeholder can simply add feedback in the form of a comment on a compensation request or an emoji reaction (thumbs-up, thumbs-down, confused face, etc).
-==== Review contributor requests ====
+There is no obligation for stakeholders to perform these reviews, but it's advised to only review compensation requests that you are knowledgeable about.
 [[Category:Processes]]

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 === Compensation Maintainer ===
-==== Announce BSQ-USD exchange rate ====
+See [[Compensation Maintainer]].
 === Contributor ===

@@ Line 7: / Line 7: @@
 ==== Announce BSQ-USD exchange rate ====
-Compensation requests [https://github.com/bisq-network/compensation/issues/519 should use a 90-day volume weighted average] to calculate a value for BSQ and mitigate its volatility. At the end of a Bisq DAO Cycle and beginning of a new one, the Compensation Maintainer should create a pinned issue with the title: <code>BSQ rate for Cycle X is Y.YY USD per 1 BSQ</code> and a screenshot of DAO Dashboard to announce the rates for the ongoing cycle.
+Compensation requests [https://github.com/bisq-network/compensation/issues/519 should use a 90-day volume weighted average] to calculate a value for BSQ and mitigate its volatility. At the end of a Bisq DAO Cycle and beginning of a new one, the Compensation Maintainer should create a pinned issue with the title: <code>BSQ rate for Cycle X is Y.YY USD per 1 BSQ</code> and a link to accepted proposal where this rate was determined.
 ==== Announce request submission deadline ====
@@ Line 22: / Line 22: @@
 Triage is controlled from the Compensation board, drag-and-dropping issues and using "add cards" to triage incoming issues, and directly from the issues, using the "projects" section in the right sidebar.
 ==== Archive previous cycle requests at the end of the proposal phase ====
@@ Line 37: / Line 42: @@
 Once closed, the issues will automatically transition to the <code>Done</code> column of the board where they remain for reference until they are archived at the end of the next cycle's proposal phase (as per the section above).
 === Contributor ===

@@ Line 43: / Line 43: @@
 ==== Create your compensation request issue ====
-If you wish to request compensation for the current [[Glossary#DAO Cycle|cycle]], you should [https://docs.bisq.network/compensation.html#submit-your-compensation-request create a compensation request issue] no later than '''one week prior''' to the end of the current cycle's proposal phase. This is in order to allow time for review by your [[Team Lead]]. Reminders about this deadline are sent every cycle to the [https://github.com/bisq-network/teams/dao @bisq-network/dao] team, so you should make sure you are watching discussions for that team.
+If you wish to request compensation for the current [[Glossary#DAO Cycle|cycle]], you should create a [[Submit_compensation_request|compensation request issue]] no later than '''one week prior''' to the end of the current cycle's proposal phase. This is in order to allow time for review by your [[Team Lead]]. Reminders about this deadline are sent every cycle to the [https://github.com/bisq-network/teams/dao @bisq-network/dao] team, so you should make sure you are watching discussions for that team.
 WIP (Work in Progress) compensation requests may be submitted with a <code>[WIP]</code> prefix in the title, e.g. <code>[WIP] For Cycle 10</code>. Such WIP requests are assumed not to be ready for review until the WIP prefix is removed. This allows you a convenient way to incrementally add content to a compensation request throughout the course of a cycle without triggering a review prematurely. To indicate that a WIP compensation request is now ready for review, remove the <code>[WIP]</code> prefix from the compensation request issue and add a comment stating ''"This request is ready for review"''. Any compensation request submitted without a WIP prefix will be assumed to be ready for review.

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:59, 20 June 2020
Line 56:		Line 56:

	When your team lead or other stakeholders review your compensation request, they will provide any feedback or requests for changes in the form of a comment on your request issue. Please respond to it promptly. When there is no further feedback, your team lead will add a comment asking you to submit this compensation request as a DAO proposal. The instructions how to do so are in the next section.		When your team lead or other stakeholders review your compensation request, they will provide any feedback or requests for changes in the form of a comment on your request issue. Please respond to it promptly. When there is no further feedback, your team lead will add a comment asking you to submit this compensation request as a DAO proposal. The instructions how to do so are in the next section.
		+
		+	Exception: If your contribution proposal consists solely of Bonded Roles for the Ops Team, which are pre-approved in the Ops Budget and allocated to you, and you are still running those nodes as expected, then you can skip the Team Lead Review as per https://github.com/orgs/bisq-network/teams/ops/discussions/1

	==== Submit your request as a DAO proposal ====		==== Submit your request as a DAO proposal ====

@@ Line 59: / Line 59: @@
 ==== Submit your request as a DAO proposal ====
-Follow the instructions on how to [https://docs.bisq.network/compensation.html#file-your-compensation-request-in-the-dao file your compensation request as a DAO proposal]. When complete, add a comment to your proposal issue that includes the transaction ID of your proposal.
+Follow the instructions on how to [https://docs.bisq.network/compensation.html#file-your-compensation-request-in-the-dao file your compensation request as a DAO proposal]. When complete, add a comment to your proposal issue that includes the transaction ID of your proposal. <!-- Wait until team lead review is complete before taking this step -->
 === Team Lead ===